Vs comparison
MyStubs vs ThePayStubs
Established paystub-generator brand with a long-running template library and broad form coverage.
Honest comparisons
MyStubs vs other paystub generators.
We named what each competitor does well, not just where we win. Pricing as of 2026-06-01 — public pricing can change, so click through to each competitor's site for the current number before deciding.
Pick a comparison
Choose the competitor you're weighing.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs PayStubHero
Branded paystub generator known for an opinionated template-first UI.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs PaystubsNow
Mid-priced paystub generator with broad template coverage.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs MakePaystubPro
Budget-tier paystub generator with a simple one-page checkout.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs PayStubDirect
Direct-to-PDF paystub generator with minimal UI.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs Gusto
Full-service payroll, benefits, and HR platform for small and mid-sized businesses with employees on payroll.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs ADP Run
Small-business arm of ADP, the largest U.S. payroll provider — full-service payroll + tax filing + HR add-ons.
Vs comparison
MyStubs vs QuickBooks Payroll
Intuit's payroll add-on for QuickBooks Online users — payroll integrated with the accounting platform most small businesses already use.
Ready To Create?
Skip the comparison and try the preview
Every generator on this page charges before you see the document. Ours shows you the finished paystub first.